N
Written by
NIBA
Published
Reading time
5 min
There was a time, not too long ago, when broker-dealers were perceived as providing value to their customers. They would get on the phone, chat to customers, talk about the markets, and ultimately provide the order placement mechanisms we all relied on to execute our trades. Those days are long gone. With the rise of technology and direct market execution, many broker-dealers and especially introducing brokers have been disintermediated in the trading process. Many introducing brokers specifically have been demoted to being the sales arms of larger broker-dealers, earning pennies in commissions.

In his book “Zero to One”, Pieter Thiel (one of PayPal’s founders) writes about how difficult it is for companies to compete in completely commoditized industries, Thiel calls it “perfect competition” – where there is little, if any value proposition or differentiation between competitors. This is true across many industries, for example in the field of computer networks, where the 1990’s where dictated by companies like CISCO selling network infrastructure to enable communication. However, these days we take the infrastructure for granted and focus on what value we can get from the data that flows over the infrastructure – hence the rise of the term “big data”. Companies like IBM have transformed themselves – they no longer sell hardware, they sell value-added services.

In the same light, BDs and IBs continue to promote “tight spreads”, “fast execution”, “excellent service”, but are quick to forget that all their competitors are saying the same thing. Traders take these “value propositions” for granted, and therefore discount their value. In fact, with the mass-market availability of high end trading platforms, “tight spreads” and “fast execution” are now the new norm, not a benefit.

Perhaps it’s time for BDs and IBs to start changing the status-quo, and start adding more value to their customers. I met an interesting group of guys at the July meeting of the NIBA that are trying to do just that, change the status quo and value proposition of BDs and IBs. They represent and company called Delkos Research, and their tools got me thinking about the possibilities – that perhaps it is time to start changing the way in which BDs and IBs interact with their customers, and start coming of age with new marketing and customer retention techniques.

Delkos is trying to create a value-added product for use by BDs and IBs through provision of identification of support and resistance levels (which after a quick Google search reveals this is the primary strength of their parent company). But one cannot help and think how this idea of value-added service can be applied in many different ways in our industry. Sure one can start with support/resistance, but this can quickly grow to other areas of technology, maybe sentiment analysis, news analysis, who knows!

The bottom line is this, it’s time to start differentiating.

Once of Delkos’s founders, Ilan Azbel will be at the September conference in Chicago; he certainly is an interesting guy to speak to; so meet him there, give him a call on 5127058482, or email him: info@delkos.com

Support Level Chart

An example of a support level identified by Delkos on Nasdaq 100 E-mini future

Stay Informed

Subscribe to the NIBA Journal for the latest insights and industry updates

Related Articles

View All
Member Announcements

Special Alert: Introducing Brokers will be featured at FIA EXPO 2025

FIA Futures and Options Expo returns to the Sheraton Grand Chicago Riverwalk November 17 & 18th. SPECIAL ALERT: For the first time in several years, Introducing Brokers will be featured at EXPO. On Tuesday, November 18, 3:15pm IBs will present a panel you don't want to miss! Introduced by Melinda Schramm, President of MHS Capital Resource and Founder & Chairman of the NIBA, the panel includes: Morad Askar, EdgeClear Elaine Levin, Powerhouse TL Steve Petillo, Pinion Global Abbey Wilkins, Sweet Futures Matt Kluchenek, Katten Muchin This panel will discuss how Introducing Brokers are viewing and meeting industry and technology changes that are impacting our relationships with our customers, our FCMs and our trading platforms. Click here to view the full...

Member Announcements

From the Classroom to the Trading Floor

There is no single, clearly defined education path for entering the derivatives industry as professionals come from a range of academic backgrounds. Still, higher education plays a crucial role in preparing students for success in this complex and fast-evolving field. A strong foundation in finance, economics, and mathematics is essential. At the undergraduate level, students should prioritize courses in financial markets and institutions, investment analysis, corporate finance, and introductory derivatives. Just as important are courses in statistics and calculus, which help build the analytical and quantitative skills required for understanding pricing models, volatility, and risk management strategies. With the increasing reliance on algorithmic trading and quantitative research, a concentration or minor in applied mathematics, data science, or computer programming can...

Member Announcements

From Insight to Impact: Building a Risk-Smart Community

With a more complex global environment and continuous financial innovation, new and more sophisticated areas of risk have emerged. At the same time, rapid advances in artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning offer powerful opportunities for private sector firms and financial institutions to enhance their risk management capabilities. Honoring a Legacy: The Founding and Mission of the Arditti Center Founded in 2006, the Arditti Center for Risk Management honors the life and legacy of the late Fred Arditti - a distinguished economist, pioneer in the futures industry, and former executive at the Chicago Mercantile Exchange - who also served as a member of DePaul University's finance faculty. The Center promotes the development of the risk management field by bridging the...